- If a Jewish soldier dies in a war against an enemy, and the war ends with a peace treaty, should the soldier be mentioned with the honorific HY”D or z”l? If HY”D – do we ask G-d to take revenge on his killer in an individual way? To punish the enemy army as a collective even though they concluded peace with us?
- What would be the appropriate honorific for a Jewish person killed by a non-Jew who later became Jewish?
- Lastly, what would be the appropriate honorific for a Jewish person (a soldier or a civilian) killed by another Jewish person who, for whatever reason, decided to help a non-Jewish enemy (hypothetically, a Jewish person who joined a militant group that attacks Israelis. There have been, in the past, members of a far-left Israeli group convicted of collaboration with the PLO and the Syrian army)?
submitted by /u/DatDudeOverThere
[link] [comments]
Source: Reditt
