Not fitting in at synagogue?

I am in the process of becoming Jewish, and have been going to this Reconstructionist synagogue since May reliably. Whenever I can attend Shabbatt morning service I do, same with Friday evening, but with work and all it’s not that easy. However, I admit… I feel like maybe this isn’t the right place for me. Not that I don’t want to be Jewish, I do, but I don’t know if that synagogue is right. Like, I wish for a far more traditional shacharit service, wish more folk donned tallit, and we had more traditional prayers. I am not sure what I should do about this, since the only other synagogue around is a Chabad House that is out of walking distance. I’d appreciate any input.