How to make guy-friends if I don’t click with anyone at shul?

I need a guy-friend for emotional and spiritual support. And to do “guy things” with, like fishing, shooting, etc. Someone who won’t judge me no matter what I tell them, and who’d feel comfortable sharing things with me as well.

I go to a gym 2x a week, but it’s all gentiles, and they don’t “get” the religious Judaism culture as well as someone who’s in it.

I’m more Yeshivish and very Torah observant (don’t have movies or secular music in our house, that type of stuff), but I grew up modern-Orth, and I feel like it’s harder to find someone to connect to.

My ideal situation is to have a guy-friend whom I can say, play pool or shoot skeet with once a week on a consistent schedule.