Press "Enter" to skip to content

What would modern judaism consider as "derived beliefs" that can be found in derived abrahamic religions?

These are christianity and islam mainly. But i’m quite skeptical that the way this works (chronologically at least) is that what comes in a secondary source in an earlier religion, turns authentic when it, or a modified version of it appears in primary sources in later scriptures like the new testament or the quran right?

For example, the quran appears to have some of its “satan story” details coming from legends of the jews, the ones regarding the refusal of bowing down to adam.

Book of revelations also assumes that the fall did happen even though it’s not mentioned in the torah. And the vague description of “lucifer” in isiah could as well be talking about the babylonian king.

Not to mention derived beliefs like islamic demonology being jinn related as there exists an entire “jinn chapter” in the quran and jinn are nowhere found in the bible. At least, not in a way where you’d find a jewish or a christian sect believing in jinn anyway. Same goes for the christian belief in fallen angels. It’s equally non-biblical. As when sticking with the old testament, one can’t even deduct free will for angels.

So the straight secular answer for this is that, when a religion comes centuries after another religion, it’ll base its core beliefs based on the scriptures or narrations that were available for the spiritual leader who made the religion in the first place along with the small group of people closest to him. Going by it that way, one can say that christianity and islam are influenced by non-jewish sources such as Zoroastrianism or greeko-roman mythologies and be done with it. Personally if that was enough for me i wouldn’t be asking xd. So is there more to this case than that? Thanks for clarifying.

submitted by /u/Infamous_Contact3582
[link] [comments]
Source: Reditt