I haven’t read most of the relevant source material, but I’ve heard Jewish Atheists accuse Chazal of making unequivocal scientific errors such as claiming that the womb has three separate chambers, that the earth is flat, that donkey urine can cure jaundice, and other things that modern science would contest. This raises the question for me as to whether or not there can be a situation where Chazal can potentially be wrong about something, and if not how do I rationalize perceived scientific discrepancies that they may have made?
Can chazal ever be wrong?
More from r/JudaismMore posts in r/Judaism »
- Does a hoodie count as a head covering from a halachic perspective?
- Are hassidic jews very orthodox or not?
- Olivia Newton-John, ‘Grease’ star and granddaughter of Jewish Nobel laureate, dies at 73
- If this happened anywhere else the Jewish world would be up in arms. Where are the condemnations?